Why Marx Was a Bad Driver: Alienation to Sensuality in the Anthropology of Automobility
نویسنده
چکیده
Contemporary automobilities research is characterised by a fundamental paradox-recognition of driving as a sensate experience alongside a tendency to emphasise the driver’s sensory disengagement from, rather than engagement with the bodily, social and environmental contexts with which s/he interacts. In this article, which builds on previous empirical work I have published, only now in a more theoretical and comparative directions, I undertake three tasks. I locate automobilities researches’ concern with the senses in its broader contexts of substantive enquiry-namely, the “Mobilities Paradigm” and the social scientific study of the “Senses”. I posit the theoretical basis of the representation of sensory disengagement in driving in automobilities research, specifically in post-war Marxian thought and its critique of Capitalist Modernity and concern with alienation. Lastly, I review three anthropological case studies that represent sensory engagement in driving, one from Palestine, one from Turkey and my own from Bosnia and Herzegovina. I go on to suggest that the approach they share, which is indicative of a growing trend towards the anthropological study of automobilities, is valuable in two ways. It is a corrective to the inappropriate representation of sensory disengagement that is a characteristic of most automobilities research. Also, through its ability to convey sensory engagement in driving, I argue that it provides important insights on the contemporary nature of enduring, but now increasingly mobile social phenomena such as, as in these particular cases sectarian enclosure, class segregation, and ethnic-national transition.
منابع مشابه
South Asia Multidisciplinary Academic Journal, 13 | 2016
In this article, selected evidence from contemporary India and Bangladesh is analyzed to identifythe diverse mechanisms of land alienation at work. A typology of such mechanisms is developedfor this purpose, based on a critical review of theoretical approaches to primitive accumulation(Marx 1976) and accumulation by dispossession (ABD) (Harvey 2005). In this typology,mechanisms ...
متن کاملFrom alienation to relation: Modes of production in crowd work
While crowdsourcing has proved to be a useful method in several contexts, the power relations in crowdsourced processes remain largely unexamined. For designing better crowdsourcing technologies and processes, it is important to understand those power structures and relations within the crowd itself as well as between the participants: who has the power, what is being produced through crowdsour...
متن کاملThe DisillusionmenT of sTuDenTs DenieD ADmission To A PreferreD mAjor VieweD from The PersPecTiVe of A PsychologicAl Theory of AlienATion
Why students respond differently when they are denied admission to a preferred academic major may be explained using a psychological theory of alienation. Using this theoretical perspective, three trajectories producing feelings of alienation are presented. The most intense of these trajectories, the process of disillusionment, is examined using a typology of behavioral responses based on the n...
متن کاملAnalysis of the Relationship between Hysteresis at Campus Field Level and Academic Alienation
Academic alienation, as one of the forms of alienation mean the separation of students from the learning process and the experience of isolation from a school or college group that a person must belong to it or be involved in it. The present study tries to analyze the academic alienation and its dimensions among university students on the one hand and the relationship between repugnance at the ...
متن کاملFrom Alienation to Revolution: A Defense of Marx’s Theory of Alienation
The following discussion presents an overview of Marx’s theory of alienation. In contrast to the usual presentation of the subject, we will demonstrate that Marx’s theory of alienation is unintelligible without a prior assimilation of the philosophical method by which it was derived. This in turn leads to a major problem. The philosophical outlook and categories employed by Marx are quite forei...
متن کامل